I quite like Claire.
I'm not sure about her as a captain though. I'll give her a chance, of course, but the thought of Amanda Keller being back on TV did make me happy for a bit...
I think they'd've been crazy to try and do the show without at least one of the captains coming back though.
[Edit]
SMH is reporting the same thing. Might be where TVTonight got their info from, don't know, they don't cite a source.